Stackbook Try it on one past job

Example, invented data. No real firm, facility or test.

Sample report check

What a check looks like when it comes back: each mismatch with the page it is on, what the other documents say and what to look at. Your reviewer decides what to change.

Download this check (PDF)

Job
Example Station, Engine 2 outlet (invented)
Unit
Natural gas engine, 1,380 hp
Methods
EPA Methods 3A, 7E and 10; 3 runs
Checked
Final report (96 pages), field data workbook, ERT project file
Result
3 mismatches, 1 question, 1 wording note. Everything else agrees.

Mismatches

  1. Mismatch

    Run 2 NOx at 15% O2: the ERT file differs from the report

    SourceWhereValue, ppmvd
    Report, results tablep. 147.96
    Field data workbook, DAS exportrow 4187.96
    ERT file, run dataRun 2, NOx9.76

    The report and the field data agree. The ERT entry looks like the same digits in another order. The test average in the ERT file changes with it.

  2. Mismatch

    Average CO does not follow from the three runs

    RunWhereCO, ppmvd at 15% O2
    Run 1p. 2241.2
    Run 2p. 2242.9
    Run 3p. 2242.8
    Average of the runs, recomputed42.3
    Average as printedp. 2241.8

    The printed average is 0.5 ppm lower than the average of the printed runs. The ERT file carries the runs, so ERT will show 42.3.

  3. Mismatch

    NOx mid-level gas: the certificate and the calibration sheet disagree

    SourceWhereCertified value, ppm
    Cylinder certificate, cylinder EX-0412 (invented)p. 6145.2
    Calibration sheetp. 5854.2
    ERT file, gas cylinder listEX-041254.2

    The certified value enters the calibration error, the system bias and every bias-corrected run result. With the certificate's 45.2 ppm, the pre-test calibration error for this gas is outside the Method 7E limit of 2.0 percent of span.

Question

  1. Question

    Was the engine tested at the load the rule asks for?

    The report gives the engine load as 82 percent during all three runs (p. 9). 40 CFR 63.6620(b) asks for a test within plus or minus 10 percent of 100 percent load for this engine class. The report does not say why the load was lower. There may be an approval we can't see.

Wording

  1. Wording

    "Turbine" in an engine report

    The introduction on p. 3 says "the turbine was operated at normal load". Every other page describes a reciprocating engine. This reads like text carried over from another job.

Checked, nothing to report

  • Runs 1 and 3: report, field data and ERT file agree for NOx, CO and O2
  • Calibration error, system bias and drift for O2 and CO, against the Method 7E limits
  • Gas cylinders certified before the test and not expired
  • Every calibration in the ERT file uses a cylinder on the cylinder list
  • Run start and end times in order on the test day
  • Units fit each gas: O2 in percent, NOx and CO in ppm
  • O2-corrected values follow from the measured ones
  • Every field ERT requires is filled in

Stackbook never declares compliance and never signs or submits. Your reviewer decides on each item and your firm authorizes the report.